Document Type : Original Article
Authors
Abstract
Private hospital services (PHS) with the undeniable effects on the Universal Health Coverage (UHC)
goals have a considerable contribution to the health system of developing countries. The purpose of
this systematic scoping review (ScR) was to identify and map the available evidence regarding the
developing countries to scrutinize the nature of the PHS toward UHC through providing graphical/
tabular information of the records trends and types, sources of the records, frequent settings, drivers
of the PHS growth, range of the PHS, behaviors of the PHS, and opportunities for policy actions.
This study was performed following the 2017 published methodological guidance of the Joanna
Briggs Institute for the conduct of ScR. Furthermore, a narrative‑thematic synthesis integrated with
the systematic analysis applying approach to health system strengthening (HSS) through systems
thinking was employed. Thirty‑two included records in English that met the inclusion criteria were
found between 2011 and July 2020. There has been a sharp increase in the generation of the records
with a 90.6% growth rate between 2015 and 2020. The most frequent records types were review
article, and the lancet was the most specialized journal. India was the most frequent country. Near
half of the growth drivers of PHS have been originated from the governance. Besides, the range of
PHS was identified only about Mongolia, and the significant frequency of codes of the PHS behaviors
(32.6%) was related to integrated people‑centered health service delivery. 47.8% of the identified HSS
interventions were recommended about governance. Governance plays a decisive role in the nature
of the PHS in UHC. Concerning the dynamic architectures of interactions between health system
functions, probably the countries themselves have realized the importance of the governance role in
the HSS than other functions. Given the all of the recommended interventions were a combination of
foundational and institutional, sustainable participation of PHS in the health system seems far and
requires a solid will of the governments. Future research is needed about the range of PHS and its
behaviors in terms of consumables, revenue‑raising, and pooling of funds.
Keywords
- FallahR, Bazrafshan A. Participation of delivering private hospital
services in universal health coverage: A systematic scoping review
of the developing countries’ evidence. J Edu Health Promot
2021;10:13.
2. Russo G. The role of the private sector in health services: Lessons
for ASEAN. ASEAN Econ Bull 1994;11:190‑211.
3. WHO Regional Office for Africa. Leave No One Behind:
Strengthening Health Systems for UHC and the SDGs in Africa.
Brazzaville: WHO; 2017.
4. Frenk J, Gómez‑Dantés O. Health systems in Latin America: The
search for universal health coverage. Arch Med Res 2018;49:79‑83.
5. Godinho MA, Jonnagaddala J, Gudi N, Islam R, Narasimhan P,
Liaw ST. mHealth for integrated people‑centred health services
in the western Pacific: A systematic review. Int J Med Inform
2020;142:104259.
6. World Health Organization, Organisation for Economic
Co‑Operation and Development, and The World Bank. Delivering
Quality Health Services: A Global Imperative for Universal Health
Coverage. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2018.
7. Kieny MP, Bekedam H, Dovlo D, Fitzgerald J, Habicht J,
Harrison G, et al. Strengthening health systems for universal
health coverage and sustainable development. Bull World Health
Organ 2017;95:537‑9.
8. De Savigny D, Adam T, editors. Systems Thinking for Health
Systems Strengthening. Alliance for Health Policy and Systems
Research. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2009.
9. Zaidi S, RiazA, TaverA, MukhiA, KhanLA. Role and contribution
of private sector in moving towards universal health coverage in
the eastern Mediterranean region 2012. Available from: http://
ecommons.aku.edu/pakistan_fs_mc_chs_chs/193. [Last accessed
on 2019 Jun 20].
10. Regional Committee for the Eastern Mediterranean Office of
World Health Organization F‑ns. Health Systems Strengthening
in Countries of the Eastern Mediterranean Region: Challenges,
Priorities and Options for Future Action. Cairo: World Health
Organization; 2013.
11. Marriott A. Blind optimism: Challenging the myths about private
health care in poor countries. Oxfam Policy Pract 2009;6:1‑55. - 12. Horwitz J. Nonprofit ownership, private property, and public
accountability: Implementing policies that undermine the private
nature of nonprofits is risky. Health Aff 2006;25 Suppl 1:W308‑11.
13. Tiemann O, Schreyögg J, Busse R. Hospital ownership and
efficiency: A review of studies with particular focus on Germany.
Health Policy 2012;104:163‑71.
14. Herrera CA, Rada G, Kuhn‑Barrientos L, Barrios X. Does
ownership matter? An overview of systematic reviews of the
performance of private for‑profit, private not‑for‑profit and public
healthcare providers. PLoS One 2014;9:e93456.
15. World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Eastern
Mediterranean. Analysis of the Private Health Sector in Countries
of the Eastern Mediterranean: Exploring Unfamiliar Territory.
Cairo: World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Eastern
Mediterranean; 2014.
16. Zaidi S, Saligram P, Ahmed S, Sonderp E, Sheikh K. Expanding
access to healthcare in South Asia. BMJ 2017;357:j1645.
17. Aromataris E, MunnZ, editors. Joanna Briggs Institute Reviewer’s
Manual. Adelaide: Joanna Briggs Institute; 2017. Available from:
https://reviewersmanual.joannabriggs.org/. [Last accessed on
2019 May 20].
18. Tricco AC, Lillie E, Zarin W, O’Brien KK, Colquhoun H, Levac D,
et al. PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA‑ScR):
Checklist and explanation. Ann Intern Med 2018;169:467‑73.
19. Kastner M, Tricco AC, Soobiah C, Lillie E, Perrier L, Horsley T,
et al. What is the most appropriate knowledge synthesis method
to conduct a review? Protocol for a scoping review. BMC Med
Res Methodol 2012;12:114.
20. Munn Z, Peters MD, Stern C, Tufanaru C, McArthur A,
Aromataris E. Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for
authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review
approach. BMC Med Res Methodol 2018;18:143.
21. Peters MD, Godfrey CM, Khalil H, McInerney P, Parker D,
Soares CB. Guidance for conducting systematic scoping reviews.
Int J Evid Based Healthc 2015;13:141‑6.
22. Clarke D, Doerr S, Hunter M, Schmets G, Soucat A, Paviza A. The
private sector and universal health coverage. Bull World Health
Organ 2019;97:434‑5.
23. European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and
Working Conditions. Delivering Hospital Services: A Greater
Role for the Private Sector? Luxembourg: Publications Office of
the European Union; 2017.
24. Pearson M, Colombo F, Murakami Y, James C. Universal Health
Coverage and Health Outcomes. Final Report for the G7 Health
Ministerial Meeting, Paris; 2016. Available from: https://www.oecd.
org/els/health‑systems/Universal‑Health‑Coverage‑and‑Health
‑Outcomes‑OECD‑G7‑Health‑Ministerial‑2016.pdf.[Last accessed
on 2019 Nov 19].
25. World Health Organization. The World Health Report 2010‑Health
Systems Financing: The Path to Universal Coverage. Geneva:
World Health Organization; 2010. Available from: http://www.
who.int/whr/en/index.html. [Last accessed on 2019 Oct 20].
26. United Nations. World Economic Situation and Prospects 2020.
New York. United Nations; 2020. Available from: https://unctad.
org/en/PublicationsLibrary/wesp2020_en.pdf.[Last accessed on
2019 Nov 19].
27. Reddy KS, Patel V, Jha P, Paul VK, Kumar AK, Dandona L,
et al. India: Towards Universal Health Coverage 7 Towards
achievement of universal health care in India by 2020: A call to
action. Lancet 2011;377:760‑8.
28. Morgan R, Ensor T, Waters H. Performance of private sector
health care: Implications for universal health coverage. Lancet
2016;388:606‑12.
29. Mackintosh M, Channon A, Karan A, Selvaraj S, Cavagnero E,
Zhao H. What is the private sector? Understanding private
provision in the health systems of low‑income and middle‑income
countries. Lancet 2016;388:596‑605.
30. Montagu D, Goodman C. Prohibit, constrain, encourage, or
purchase: How should we engage with the private health‑care
sector? Lancet 2016;388:613‑21.
31. McPake B, Hanson K. Managing the public‑private mix to achieve
universal health coverage. Lancet 2016;388:622‑30.
32. Tsevelvaanchig U, Gouda H, Baker P, Hill PS. Role of emerging
private hospitals in a post‑Soviet mixed health system: A mixed
methods comparative study of private and public hospital
inpatient care in Mongolia. Health Policy Plan 2017;32:476‑86.
33. Gele AA, Ahmed MY, Kour P, Moallim SA, Salad AM, Kumar B.
Beneficiaries of conflict: A qualitative study of people’s trust in the
private health care system in Mogadishu, Somalia. Risk Manag
Healthc Policy 2017;10:127‑35.
34. SeanCN, SparksS, NelsonG. Organizing the Private Sector to Support
Universal Health Coverage Goals. Bethesda, MD. Sustaining Health
Outcomes through the Private Sector Plus Project, Abt Associates;
2017. Available from: https://www.shopsplusproject.org/
resource‑center/organizing‑private‑sector‑support‑universal
‑health‑coverage‑goals. [Last accessed on 2019 Nov 19].
35. Wadge H, Roy R, Sripathy A, Fontana G, Marti J, Darzi A. How
to harness the private sector for universal health coverage. Lancet
2017;390:e19‑20.
36. Maurya D, Virani A, Rajasulochana S. Horses for courses: Moving
India towards universal health coverage through targeted policy
design. Appl Health Econ Health Policy 2017;15:733‑44.
37. Alami R. Health financing systems, health equity and universal
health coverage in Arab countries. Dev Change 2017;48:146‑79.
38. Zodpey S, Farooqui HH. Universal health coverage in India:
Progress achieved & the way forward. Indian J Med Res
2018;147:327‑9.
39. Makinde OA, Sule A, Ayankogbe O, Boone D. Distribution of
health facilities in Nigeria: Implications and options for Universal
Health Coverage. Int J Health Plann Manage 2018;33:e1179‑92.
40. Tangcharoensathien V, Witthayapipopsakul W ,
Panichkriangkrai W, Patcharanarumol W, Mills A. Health
systems development in Thailand: A solid platform for
successful implementation of universal health coverage. Lancet
2018;391:1205‑23.
41. Kwon S. Advancing Universal Health Coverage: What Developing
Countries Can Learn from the Korean Experience? Universal
Health Care Coverage Series No. 33. Washington, DC: World
Bank Group; 2018.
42. World Health Organization, Regional Office for the Eastern
Mediterranean. Regional Committee for the Eastern Mediterranean
Sixty‑fifth Session‑Provisional Agenda Item 4(e): Private Sector
Engagement for Advancing Universal Health Coverage; 2018.
Available from: http://applications.emro.who.int/docs/
RC_Technical_Papers_2018_8_20546_EN.pdf. [Last accessed on
2019 Nov 19].
43. Lu JR, Chiang TL. Developing an adequate supply of health
services: Taiwan’s path to Universal Health Coverage. Soc Sci
Med 2018;198:7‑13.
44. Tsevelvaanchig U, Narula IS, Gouda H, Hill PS. Regulating
the for‑profit private healthcare providers towards universal
health coverage: A qualitative study of legal and organizational
framework in Mongolia. Int J Health Plann Manage 2018;33:185‑201.
45. Chapman AR, Dharmaratne SD. Sri Lanka and the possibilities
of achieving universal health coverage in a poor country. Glob
Public Health 2019;14:271‑83.
46. Erdenee O, Narula IS, Yamazaki C, Kameo S, Koyama H.
Mongolian health sector strategic master plan (2006-2015):
A foundation for achieving universal health coverage. Int J Health
Plann Manage 2019;34(1):e314‑26. [doi: 10.1002/hpm. 2651].
47. Zhu A, Tang S, Thu NT, Supheap L, Liu X. Analysis of strategies
to attract and retain rural health workers in Cambodia, China,
and Vietnam and context influencing their outcomes. Hum Resour
Health 2019;17:2. - 48. Cowley P, Chu A. Comparison of private sector hospital
involvement for UHC in the western pacific region. Health Syst
Reform 2019;5:59‑65.
49. Yip W, Fu H, Chen AT, Zhai T, Jian W, Xu R, et al. 10 years of
health‑care reform in China: Progress and gaps in Universal
Health Coverage. Lancet 2019;394:1192‑204.
50. Danaei G, Farzadfar F, Kelishadi R, Rashidian A, Rouhani OM,
Ahmadnia S, et al. Iran in transition. Lancet 2019;
393(10184):1984‑2005. [doi: 10.1016/S0140‑6736(18)33197‑0].
51. Titoria R, Mohandas A. A glance on public private partnership:
An opportunity for developing nations to achieve universal health
coverage. Int J Community Med Public Health 2019;6:1353‑7.
52. Stewart J, Wolvaardt G. Hospital management and health
policy – A South African perspective. J Hosp Manag Health Policy
2019;3:14. [doi: 10.21037/jhmhp. 2019.06.01].
53. Khoonthaweelapphon Woraset. The Liberalization of Thailand
Medical Services Industry‑Case Study between Thailand and
SouthKorea, Master’s Thesis of International Commerce. Graduate
School of International Studies, Seoul National University; 2019.
Available from: http://hdl.handle.net/10371/150912. [Last
accessed on 2019 Oct 11].
54. Asbu EZ, Masri MD, Al Naboulsi M. Determinants of hospital
efficiency: A literature review. Int J Healthcare 2020;6:44‑53.
55. Mays N, Pope C, Popay J. Systematically reviewing qualitative
and quantitative evidence to inform management and
policy‑making in the health field. J Health Serv Res Policy
2005;10 1 Suppl: 6‑20.
56. Gale NK, Heath G, Cameron E, Rashid S, Redwood S. Using
the framework method for the analysis of qualitative data in
multi‑disciplinary health research. BMC Med Res Methodol
2013;13:117.
57. Kumar AK, Chen LC, Choudhury M, Ganju S, Mahajan V,
Sinha A, et al. India: Towards Universal Health Coverage 6
Financing health care for all: Challenges and opportunities. Lancet
(London, England) 2011;377:668‑79.
58. European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and
Working Conditions. Impacts of the Crisis on Access to Healthcare
Services in the EU; Dublin; 2013.
59. Kutzin J. Health financing for universal coverage and health
system performance: Concepts and implications for policy. Bull
World Health Organ 2013;91:602‑11.
60. World Health Organization. Together on the Road to Universal
Health Coverage: A Call to Action. Geneva: World Health
Organization; 2017.
)