Document Type : Original Article
Authors
- . Zahra Kazempour
- . Mohammad Reza Soleymani 1
- . Nayere Sadat Soleimanzade Najafi 2
- . Hasan Ashrafi‑rizi 3
1 Department of Medical Library and Information Science, Health Information Technology Research Center, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
2 Department of Knowledge and Information Science, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran
3 Department of Medical Library and Informatin Science, Health Information Technology Research Center, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The best mechanisms for medical librarians to be more involved in health, especially
during crisis condition, and to expand their roles are using experiences of other individuals and
performing new activities. This study aimed to identify the roles of medical librarians in the COVID‑19
crisis in Iran.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This research was done by a qualitative content analysis method.
Research participants in the first phase included whole scientific papers (19 documents) which had
been published by medical librarians related to the COVID‑19 issue and in the second phase 10
medical librarians involved in the COVID‑19 who were interviewed and continued until data saturation.
Data were collected through each interview, and data analysis was performed using content analysis
method. Then, obtained information of the first and second phases was merged together, and codes,
subcategories as well as main categories were formed.
RESULTS: According to the results, 7 main categories and 24 subcategories regarding the roles
of librarians in COVID‑19 crisis were identified. The main categories include hygiene services
promotion, development of health information‑seeking skills, health research services, interaction‑level
development, evidence‑based policy development, information dissemination services promotion, and
management services development. Furthermore, regarding barriers to the role of medical librarians
in the COVID‑19 crisis in Iran, four subcategories were identified that are medical librarian‑related
barriers, organization‑related barriers, profession‑related barriers, and context of society (country
conditions)‑related barriers.
CONCLUSION: Medical librarians relatively have been able to provide effective health information
services to managers, health‑care specialists, and the general public in a variety of health fields.
Keywords
- State Management Education Center. Mannual of Disaster
Managemnt. Tehran: State Management Education Center; 2014.
2. Zakaeei‑fateh J. Non‑operating defense and crisis management
considerations in locating emergency medical services in crisis
situations. The 15th Conference of Civil Students of the Nation.
Tehran, Iran; 2017.
3. Mansour E. The potential role of university libraries’ manpower,
collections, services, facilities and activities in promoting national
security in times of crises in Upper Egypt. Library Manag 2017;
38(4/5):182‑202.
4. Mohammadesmaeili S, Nasehi Scouei M. Libraries and Natural
Disasters (a Case Study of Medical University Libraries Affiliated
to Ministry of Health and Medical Education of Iran, tehran); 2015.
5. Ashrafi‑Rzi H, Kazempour Z. Designing of clinical information
update system for clinicians on COVID‑19: A commentary. J Educ
Health Promot 2020;9:104.
6. Alajmi B. When the Nation is in Crisis: Libraries Respond. Library
Management; 2016.
7. The New Jersey State Library. The Librarians Disaster Planning
and Community Resilience Guidebook: Librarians Fulfilling Their
Role as Information First Responders. USA: The New Jersey State
Library; 2016.
8. Chizwina S, Rabatseta B, Bangani S, Moyo M. A University
Library’s Use of Social Media During a Time of Crisis. Library
Review; 2017.
9. Winston MD, Quinn S. Library Leadership in Times of Crisis and
Change. New Library World; 2005.
10. Linder‑Zarankin M. A Latent Resilience Capacity: Individual and
Organizational Factors Associated with Public Library Managers’
Willingness to Engage in Post‑Disaster Response and Recovery:
Virginia Tech; 2017.
11. Young E. The Role of Public Libraries in Disasters. Instructions
for Submissions; 2018. p. 31.
12. Ashrafi‑Rizi H, Kazaempour Z. The challenges of information
services related to the COVID‑19 crisis. J Mil Med 2020;22:207‑9.
13. Zach L. What do I do in an emergency? The role of public libraries
in providing information during times of crisis. Sci Technol Lib
2011;30:404‑13.
14. Stricker M. Ports in a storm: The role of the public library in times
of crisis. Collaborat Lib 2019;11:4.
15. Hariri N. Principles and Methods of Qualitative Research. Tehran:
Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch of Tehran;
2016.
16. Pasquarella C, Saccani E, Sansebastiano GE, Ugolotti M,
Pasquariello G, Albertini R, et al. Proposal for a biological
environmental monitoring approach to be used in libraries and
archives. Ann Agric Environ Med 2012;19:209‑12.
17. Pietro GD, Ligterink F, Porck H, de Bruin G. Chemical air
filtration in archives and libraries reconsidered. Stud Conservat
2016;61:245‑54.
18. Fakari FR, Simbar M. Coronavirus pandemic and worries during
pregnancy; a letter to editor. Arch Acad Emerg Med 2020;8:21.
19. Phelan AL, Katz R, Gostin LO. The novel coronavirus originating
in Wuhan, China: Challenges for global health governance. JAMA
2020;323:709‑10.
20. Yates C. Exploring variation in the ways of experiencing health
information literacy: a phenomenographic study. Lib Inf Sci Res
2015;37:220‑7.
21. Ivanitskaya L, O’Boyle I, Casey AM. Health information literacy
and competencies of information age students: Results from the
interactive online research readiness self‑assessment (RRSA).
J Med Internet Res 2006;8:e6.
22. Featherstone RM. The disaster information specialist: an emerging
role for health librarians. J Libr Administ 2012;52:731‑53.
23. Featherstone RM, Lyon BJ, Ruffin AB. Library roles in disaster
response: An oral history project by the national library of
medicine. J Med Libr Assoc 2008;96:343‑50.
24. Australian Library and Information Associaation. ALIA Guide
to Disaster Planning, Response and Recovery for Libraries.
Australian: Australian Library and Information Associaation;
2010.
25. Ashrafi‑Rizi H, Amraei M, Kargar H, Ghazavi Z, Kazempour Z.
Identification of strategies for collaboration of medical librarians
with family physicians in advancing the goals of the family
physician program based on experts’ viewpoints. J Contemp Med
Sci 2019;5:218-23. - 26. Ashrafi‑rizi H, Hodhodinejad N, Shahrzadi L, Soleymani M.
A Study on the Novel Services of Medical Librarians in Health
Information Services: A Narrative Review; 2017.
27. Davidoff F, Haynes B, Sackett D, Smith R. Evidence based
medicine. BMJ 1995;310:1085‑6.
28. Smith R. What clinical information do doctors need? BMJ
1996;313:1062‑8.
29. Sahapong S, Manmart L, Ayuvat D, Potisat S. A Systematic
Review of the Roles and Competencies of Medical Information
Professionals (Mips) in Evidence‑Based Medicine In Thailand;
2006.
30. Movahedi F, Ashrafirizi H, Sharifmoghadam H. Physicians’
perception about the role of clinical librarianship at Alzahra
Medical Center. J Health Administ 2013;16:71‑81.
31. Sheikhshoaei F, Zolfaghari M, Mansourzadeh MJ, Ghazi
Mirsaeid SJ. Designing a proposed educational program for
clinical librarian. J Health Administ 2019;22:22‑34.
32. Ashrafi‑Rizi H, Najafi NS, Kazempour Z, Taheri B. Research
self‑efficacy among students of isfahan university of medical
sciences. J Educ Health Promot 2015;4:26.
33. Demas JM, Ludwig LT. Clinical medical librarian: The last
unicorn? Bull Med Libr Assoc 1991;79:17‑27.
34. Anwar MA, Ullah M. Developing an instrument for the validation
of competencies: The case of medical librarians. Libr Philosophy
Pract 2017; 1533: 1‑24.
35. Gavgani VZ. The research and education of evidence based
library and information practice; a narrative review. Depict Health
2019;8:193‑202.
36. Yaeger LH, Kelly B. Evidence‑based medicine: Medical librarians
providing evidence at the point of care. Mo Med 2014;111:413‑5.
37. Uzohue CE, Yaya JA. Provision of current awareness services and
selective dissemination of information by medical librarians in
technological era. Am J Inf Sci Comp Eng 2016;2:8‑14.
38. Omona W, Ikoja‑Odongo R. Application of information and
communication technology (ICT) in health information access
and dissemination in Uganda. J Libr Inf Sci 2006;38:45‑55.
39. Roderer NK. Dissemination of Medical Information: Organizational
and Technological Issues in Health Sciences Libraries; 1993.
40. Mahmood K, Richardson JV. Impact of Web 2.0 Technologies on
Academic Libraries: A Survey of ARL Libraries. The Electronic
Library; 2013.
41. Beales DL. Before disaster strikes: essentials of formulating a
library emergency management plan. J Hosp Libr 2003;3:11‑24.
42. Donahue AE, Featherstone RM. New roles for hospital librarians:
A benchmarking survey of disaster management activities. J Med
Libr Assoc 2013;101:315‑8.
43. Biglu MH, Abotalebi P, Ghavami M. Job‑burnout among medical
librarians. J Anal Res Clin Med 2016;4:215‑20.
44. Lamptey R, Boateng M, Antwi I. Motivation and performance of
librarians in public universities in Ghana. Libr Philosophy Practice
2013; 911 1‑25.
45. McKnight M. Health sciences librarians’ reference services
during a disaster: More than collection protection. Med Ref Serv
Q 2006;25:1‑2.
46. Matthews G, Eden P. Disaster Management Training in Libraries.
Library Review; 1996.
47. Takian A, Raoofi A, Kazempour‑Ardebili S. COVID‑19 battle
during the toughest sanctions against iran. Lancet 2020;395:1035‑6.
48. Gorji A. Sanctions against iran: The impact on health services.
Iran J Public Health 2014;43:381‑2.
49. Ashrafi‑rizi H, Kazempour Z. Information typology
incoronavirus (COVID‑19): A commentary. Arch Acad Emerg
Med 2020;8:19.
50. Ashrafi‑Rizi H, Kazempour Z. Information diet in Covid‑19 crisis;
a commentary. Arch Acad Emerg Med 2020;8:e30.
)