Authors
- . Matthew A. Orim 1
- . Samuel O. Orim
- . Philip O. Adeleke
- . Essien E. Essien 2
- . James E. Olayi
- . Cecilia K. Essien 3
- . Oluseyi A. Dada
- . James A. Ewa
- . Vitalis U. Eke
- . Innocent U. Igba
- . Raymond O. Ogar
- . Valentine J. Owan 4
1 Department of Special Education, University of Calabar, Nigeria
2 Department of Social Science Education, University of Calabar, Nigeria
3 Department of Continuing Education and Development Studies, University of Calabar, Nigeria,
4 Department of Educational Foundations, University of Calabar, Nigeria
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Few researchers have examined the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy
in treating aggressive behaviors among individuals with dual diagnosis (intellectual disability and
mental health conditions) due to the relatively recent interest in the field of psychopathology in
intellectual disability. This study investigated the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy in
treating aggressive behaviors among clients with dual diagnoses in a community rehabilitation
center, Ibadan, Oyo state, and the moderating effects of parenting style and socioeconomic status
in the associations.
MATERIALS AND METHOD: A 2 × 2 × 2 pre‑test post‑test factorial design was used. Parenting style
and socioeconomic status at two levels each moderated the associations. A sample of 22 participants
purposively selected was exposed to treatment using cognitive behavioral therapy, while the other
five were exposed to placebo treatment all for 8 weeks. Data collected were analyzed using Line
Chart and Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA).
RESULTS: Improvements were found in the post‑treatment scores obtained on the Aggressive Scale
for Youths. A reduction in the Aggressive Incidents chart was recorded for each participant in the
treatment group when compared with the control group, using a line chart and Analysis of Covariance
(ANCOVA). Evidence also demonstrated that parenting style (authoritarian and authoritative), F (1,14)
= 0.75, P <.05, η2 =0.05), and socioeconomic status (high and low), F (1,14) = 0.01, P =0.020, η2
=.00), moderated the associations.
CONCLUSION: Cognitive behavioral therapy is seen as a treatment intervention for individuals with
intellectual disability co‑existing with mental health manifesting aggressive behaviors in the community
or other settings. This should be used to improve the client’s quality of life under these conditions.
Keywords
Child Psychol 2013;27:28‑33.
2. Durn NL. Psychopathology in young people with intellectual
disability. J Intellect Disabil Assoc 2012;296:1981‑9.
3. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical
Manual of Mental Disorders. 5th ed. Arlington: American
Psychiatric Publishing, Incr; 2013.
4. Monrea W, Hirra V. Receipt of psychotropic medication by people
with intellectual disability in residential settings. J Intellect Disabil
Res 2016;44:666‑76.
5. Aloyt L, Fenton I. Relationships between psychiatric conditions
and behaviour problems among adults with mental retardation.
J Intellect Disabil 2017;53:217‑32.
6. Lindsay CF, Taylor U, Sturmey EO. The Behavior Problems
Inventory: An instrument for the assessment of self‑injury,
stereotyped behavior, and aggression/destruction in individuals
with developmental disabilities. J Autism Dev Disord
2014;31:577‑88.
7. Hullar S, Comuta CE. Joint occurrence of depression and
aggression in children and adults with intellectual disability.
J Intellect Disabil Res 2017;37:287‑94.
8. Mollenhauer J, King S, Bodiam T, Bellamy J. Caring for a Child
with Intellectual Disability and Challenging Behaviour. Sydney:
Anglicare Diocese; 2018.
9. Luckerson JC. Olanzapine for self‑injurious, aggressive,
and disruptive behaviors in intellectually disabled adults:
A retrospective, open‑label, naturalistic trial. J Clin Psychiatry
2011;84:1258‑65.
10. Gyel BF, Russ CN. Challenging behaviour: A unified approach.
College Report CR144. 2013. Available from: https://bit.
ly/3xhcfPR.
11. VacherC, RomoL, DereureM, SolerM, PicotMC, Purper‑OuakilD.
Efficacy of cognitive behavioral therapy on aggressive behavior in
children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and emotion
dysregulation: study protocol of a randomized controlled trial.
Trials 2022;23:Article 124.
12. Jindiri I. Prevalence and types of aggressive behavior among
adults with intellectual disabilities. J Intellect Disabil Res
2016;50:652‑61.
13. Wittenboer UP. Challenging behaviors: Prevalence and
topographies. J Intellect Disabil Res 2018;51:625‑36.
14. Prout T, Nowak‑Drabik K. Psychotherapy with persons who have
mental retardation: An evaluation of effectiveness. Am J Ment
Retard 2003;108:82‑93.
15. Orim SO, OrimMA. Forensic psychotherapy for curbing offending
behaviors among clients with intellectual disability in Nigerian
rehabilitation centres. E‑Pedagogium 2018;18:86‑95.
16. Sundra DH. The effectiveness of cognitive‑behavioural play
therapy based on children with intellectual disability. Behav Sci
Res 2011;11:556‑64.
17. Agiou SV. Staff perception of aggressive behavior in community
services for adults with intellectual disabilities. Community Ment
Health J 2010;50:743‑51.
18. Nelma EB. Effectiveness of group play therapy through
cognitive‑behavioral method on social adjustment of children
with behavioral disorder. J Bus Manag Rev 2014;3:356‑62.
19. Owan VJ, Uzoamaka Duruamaku‑Dim J, Nonyelum Odigwe F,
Owan MV. Dataset of the adoption of digital tools for research
sharing among academics in African Varsities during the
COVID‑19 pandemic in 2020. F1000Res 2022;11:82.
20. Dodge RH. The effectiveness of cognitive behavioral group therapy of play therapy in reducing behavioral problems
in children with intellectual disability. J Intellect Disabil
2014;2:140‑53.
21. Loobr N. The early development of stereotypy and self‑injury:
A review of research methods. J Intellect Disabil Res
2013;49:144‑58.
22. Vault EB, Hugh C. Behavioural symptoms among people with
severe and profound intellectual disabilities: A 26‑year follow up
study. Br J Psychiatry 2016;181:67‑71.
23. Unwin G, Tsimopoulou I, Kroese BS, Azmi S. Effectiveness of
cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) for anxiety or depression in
adults with intellectual disabilities: A review of literature. Res
Dev Disabil 2016;51‑52:60‑75.
24. Akhtar P, Malik JA, Begeer S. The grandparents’ influence:
Parenting styles and social competence among children of joint
families. J Child Fam Stud 2016;26:603‑11.
25. Barrera C. Cognitive behavior therapy with adults with
intellectual disabilities: A systematic review. 2017. Retrieved from
Sophia, the St. Catherine University repository website. Available
from: https://sophia.stkate.edu/msw_papers/707/.
)