Authors
- . Zahra Eskandari 1
- . Zohreh Ghomian 2
- . Sanaz Sohrabizadeh 3
- . Ahmad Alibabaei 4
- . Hojjat Ahmadinejad 5
1 Department of Health in Disasters and Emergencies, School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 Department of Health in Disasters and Emergencies, School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, Workplace Health Promotion Research Center, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
3 Safety Promotion and Injury Prevention Research Center, School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
4 Department of E‑Learning, Virtual School of Medical Education and Management, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
5 National Center for Strategic Research in Medical Education, Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Nowadays, air ambulances have been developed as part of advanced emergency medicine services
with many countries employing these services for transferring patients in usual and emergency
conditions. However, there are challenges concerning the optimal development of air ambulance
base. The present research aimed to identify factors affecting the development of air ambulance
bases to provide the opportunity of planning to improve the quality of emergency medical services.
In this systematic literature review, the peer-reviewed papers in fiv electronic databases, including
Medline through PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, ScienceDirect, and ProQuest, as well as
available gray literature, were searched and selected. Two combinations of groups were used as
keywords: the Health Planning and development factor, air ambulance base. The focus was on
the PRISMA checklist, with no time limitations until from 1990 to January 2020. Finally, through
5156 related citations, 20 articles were included. Descriptive and thematic content analyses were
evaluated. The factors affecting the development of the air ambulance base were classified in fiv
categories and 14 subcategories as follows: navigation criteria, process indications and standards,
sociopolitical factors, and current situation of the area. There are few studies on factors affecting the
development of air ambulance bases. It is necessary to apply multidimensional models to consider
various factors for development. The development of high populated cities, events and ceremonies
with a crowd of participants, and increase of human-made disasters are making these services
increasingly indispensable.
Keywords
- Gräsner JT, Lefering R, Koster RW, Masterson S, Böttiger BW,
Herlitz J, et al. EuReCaONE, 27 nations, ONE Europe, ONEregistry:
A prospective one month analysis of out‑ofhospital cardiac arrest
outcomes in 27 countries in Europe. Resuscitation 2016;105:188‑95.
2. Earnest A, Hock Ong ME, Shahidah N, Min Ng W, Foo C,
Nott DJ. Spatial analysis of ambulance response times related to
prehospital cardiac arrests in the city‑state of Singapore. Prehosp
Emerg Care 2012;16:256‑65.
3. Oliver GJ, Walter DP, Redmond AD. Prehospital deaths from
trauma: Are injuries survivableand do bystanders help? Injury
2017;8:985‑99.
4. Safi Keykaleh M, Sohrabizadeh S. The Emergency Medical
System (EMS) response to Iraqi pilgrims’ bus crash in Iran: A case
report. BMC Emerg Med 2019;19:38.
5. Isakov A. Urgent air‑medical transport: Right patient, place and
time. CMAJ 2009;181:569‑70.
6. Kalantari Meibodi M., Alamdari SH., Mohammadi P.,
Kariman H. 2010 [Last cited on 2021 Mar 26]; 1(4):48‑52.
Available from: https://www.sid.ir/en/journal/ViewPaper.
aspx?id=203191, [In Persian].
7. Taylor CB, Stevenson M, Jan S, Middleton PM, Fitzharris M,
Myburgh JA. A systematic review of the costs and benefits of helicopter emergency medical services. Injury Prev 2010;41:10‑20.
8. Ahmadi‑Javid A, Seyedi P, Syam SS. A survey of healthcare facility
location. Comput Oper Res 2017;79:223‑63.
9. Shahbandar Zadeh H , Jamali G R , Mansouri M . Hierarchical
location‑allocation for emergency medical services. Emergency
Management, 2015;4(1):57‑86.
10. Rajagopalan H, Sadam C, Xiao J. "A Multiperiod Set Covering
Location Model for Dynamic Redeployment of Ambulances,
"Computers & Operations Research 2008;35:814-26.
11. Araz CS, Ozkarahan I. A fuzzy multi‑objective covering‑based
vehicle location model for emergency services. Comput Oper Res
2007;34:705‑26.
12. Wen MI. Facility location–allocation problem in random fuzzy
environment: Using (α,β) – Cost minimization model under the
Hurewicz criterion. Comput Math Appl 2008;55:704‑13.
13. Garner AA, van den Berg PL. Locating helicopter emergency
medical service bases to optimise population coverage versus
average response time. BMC Emerg Med 2017;17:31.
14. Røislien J, van den Berg PL, Lindner T, Zakariassen E, Aardal K,
van Essen JT. Exploring optimal air ambulance base locations
in Norway using advanced mathematical modelling. Inj Prev
2017;23:10‑5.
15. Aghajani MS, Kolivand PH, Saberinia A, Noori H, Sarvar M.
Development Air Ambulance. Tehran: Ministry of Health and
Medical Education; 2016.
16. appinen J, Olkinuora A, Laukkanen‑Nevala P. Defining a
mission‑based method to determine a HEMS unit’s actual service
area. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med 2019;27:63.
17. van den Berg PL, Fiskerstrand P, Aardal K, Einerkjær J,
Thoresen T, Røislien J. Improving ambulance coverage in a mixed
urban‑rural region in Norway using mathematical modeling.
PLoS One 2019;14:e0215385.
18. Miller M, Delroy-Buelles I, Bootland D, Lyon RM. A Spatial
Analysis of Incident Location and Prehospital Mortality for
Two United Kingdom Helicopter Emergency Medical Services
(HEMS). Appl Spatial Analysis 2020;13:575-90. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s12061-019-09318-2
19. Sorani M, Tourani S, Khankeh HR, Panahi S. Challenges of
helicopter emergency medical service: A qualitative content
analysis in Iranian context. Health Policy Technol 2018;7:374‑8.
20. Firouzi Jahantigh F, Ghaderi M. Location of the aerial ambulances
using combination of fuzzy ANP and fuzzy dematel in the
environment of ArcGIS: A case study in sistan and baluchestan
province. JHOSP 2018;17:33‑47.
21. Navazi F, Tavakkoli‑Moghaddam R, Sazvar Z. A multi‑period
location‑allocation‑inventory problem for ambulance and
helicopter ambulance stations: robust possibilistic approach. IFAC
PapersOnLine 2018;51:322‑7.
22. Røislien J, van den Berg PL, Lindner T, Zakariassen E, Uleberg O,
Aardal K, et al. Comparing population and incident data for
optimal air ambulance base locations in Norway. Scand J Trauma
Resusc Emerg Med 2018;26:42.
23. Shahriari M, Bozorgi‑Amiri A, Tavakoli S, Yousefi‑Babadi A.
Bi‑objective approach for placing ground and air ambulance base
and helipad locations in order to optimize EMS response. Am J
Emerg Med 2017;35:1873‑81.
24. Bozorgi‑Amiri A, Tavakoli S, Mirzaeipour H, Ra‑bani M,
Integrated locating of helicopter stations and helipads for
wounded trans‑fer under demand location uncertainty, American
Journal of Emergency Medicine (2016), doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.
2016.11.024
25. Hassani SA, Moharari RS, Sarvar M, Nejati A, Khashayar P.
Helicopter emergency medical service inTehran, Iran:
A descriptive study. Air Med J 2012;31:294‑7. [ In Persian].
26. Nishikawa W, Yamano Y. An overview of the development
of helicopter emergency medical services in Japan. Air Med J
2010;29:288‑91.
27. Struck MF, Weber S. The Historical Development of Helicopter
Emergency Medical Services in the German Democratic Republic.
Air Medical Journal. 2010;29(6):294‑9.
28. Erdemir ET, Batta R, Rogerson PA, Blatt A, Flanigan M.
Joint ground and air emergency medical services coverage
models: A greedy heuristic solution approach. Eur J Oper Res
2010;207:736‑49.
29. Schuurman N, Bell NJ, L’Heureux R, Hameed SM. Modelling
optimal location for pre‑hospital helicopter emergency medical
services. BMC Emerg Med 2009;9:6.
30. Erdemir ET, Batta R, Spielman S, Rogerson PA, Blatt A,
Flanigan M. Optimization of aeromedical base locations in New
Mexico using a model that considers crash nodes and paths. Accid
Anal Prev 2008;40:1105‑14.
31. Flanigan M, Blatt A, Lombardo L, Mancuso D, Miller M, Wiles D,
et al. Assessment of air medical coverage using the Atlas and
Database of Air Medical Services and correlations with reduced
highway fatality rates. Air Med J 2005;24:151‑63.
32. Heggestad T, Børsheim KY. Accessibility and distribution of the
Norwegian National Air Emergency Service: 1988‑1998. Air Med
J 2002;21:39‑45.
33. Clark DE, Hahn DR, Hall RW, Quaker RE. Optimal location
for a helicopter in a rural trauma system: Prediction using
discrete‑event computer simulation. Proc Annu Symp Comput
Appl Med Care 1994;:888‑92.
34. Judge T. HEMS: Luxury or necessity? Air Med J 2007;26:256‑8.
35. Boyd DD, Macchiarella ND. Occupant injury severity and accident
causes in helicopter emergency medical services (1983‑2014).
Aerosp Med Hum Perform 2016;87:26‑31.
36. Sarvar M, Parvaneh E, Soltani D, Seyedzadeh M, Malhagh A.
Landing Zone Officer and Helicopter zone Officer in
Operation HEMS. Tehran: National Emergency Organization;
2016.
37. Civil Aviat Authority UK’s. Standards for helicopter landing areas
at hospitals. The UK’s specialist aviation regulator (UK’s):Civil
Aviat Authority 2016.
38. Aghajani M, Shahrami A, Kolivand P, Saberinia A, Masoumi G,
Sarvar M. Check the Program Upgrading the Air Emergency
Services in the Health Transformation Plan: A Review of the
Background, Necessity, Results and Challenges. Hakim Research
Journal 20:175-85.
39. Rasmussen K, Røislien J, Sollid SJ. Does medical staffing influence
perceived safety? An international survey on medical crew models
in helicopter emergency medical services. Air Med J 2018;37:29‑36.
40. Miller JO, Thammasitboon S, Hsu DC, Shah MI, Minard CG,
Graf JM. Continuing medical education for air medical providers:
The successes and challenges. Pediatr Emerg Care 2016;32:87‑92.
41. Bjørnsen LP, Solheim AM, Uleberg O, Skogvoll E. Compliance
with a national standard by norwegian helicopter emergency
physicians. Air Med J 2018;37:46‑50.
42. Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland Safety
Guideline. Pre‑hospital Anaesthesia. 2009. Available from:
https://www.aagbi.org/sites/default/files/prehospital_
glossy09.pdf . [Last accessed on 2015 Oct 15].
43. Knotts D, Arthur AO, Holder P, Herrington T, Thomas SH.
Pneumothorax volume expansion in helicopter emergency
medical services transport. Air Med J 2013;32:138‑43.
44. Marinangeli FT, Ursini ML, Ricotti V, Varrassi G. Helicopter
emergency medical service in Italy: Reality and perspective. Air
Med J 2007;6:292‑8.
45. Den Hartog D, Romeo J, Ringburg AN, Verhofstad MH, Van
Lieshout EM. Survival benefit of physician‑staffed Helicopter
Emergency Medical Services (HEMS) assistance for severely
injured patients. Injury 2015;46:1281‑6.
46. Sahebi A, Ghomian Z, Sarvar M. Helicopter emergency medical
services in 2017 Kermanshah earthquake; a qualitative study.
Arch Acad Emerg Med 2019;7:e31. - 47. Brown JB, Gestring ML, Guyette FX, Rosengart MR, Stassen NA,
Forsythe RM, et al. Helicopter transport improves survival
following injury in the absence of a time‑saving advantage.
Surgery 2016;159:947‑59.
48. Brown JB, Gestring ML, Guyette FX, Rosengart MR, Stassen NA,
Forsythe RM, et al. External validation of the Air Medical
Prehospital Triage score for identifying trauma patients likely
to benefit from scene helicopter transport. J Trauma Acute Care
Surg 2017;82:270‑9.
49. Adam Chesters PH, Timothy J. Hodgetts perceptions and culture
of safety among helicopter emergency medical service personnel
in the UK. Emerg Med J 2016;33:801‑6.
50. Baker SP, Grabowski JG, Dodd RS, Shanahan DF, Lamb MW,
Li GH. EMS helicopter crashes: What influences fatal outcome?
Ann Emerg Med 2006;47:351‑6.
51. Boyd, Douglas D, Macchiarella, Nickolas D. Occupant injury
severity and accident causes in helicopter emergency medical
services. Aerospace medicine and human performance.
2016;87(1):26‑31.
52. Winn WT. HEMS simulator training for safety and clinical
proficiency. Air Med J 2010;29:300‑3.
53. Ringburg AN, de Ronde G, Thomas SH, van Lieshout EM, Patka P,
Schipper IB. Validity of helicopter emergency medical services
dispatch criteria for traumatic injuries: A systematic review.
Prehosp Emerg Care 2009;13:28‑36.
54. Thomson DP TS. Guidelines for air medical dispatch. Prehosp
Emerg Care. 2003;7:265‑71.
55. Fattahi PH, Chobtashan M, Sepehri M. Modeling and solving the
problem of locating ambulance stations, a review study. In: 12th
International Industrial Engineering Conference 2015. https://
civilica.com/doc/516137.
56. Wilde ET. Do emergency medical system response times matter
for health outcomes? Health Econ 2013;22:790‑806.
57. Jalali A Vital Supports: Basic, Advanced. Tehran: 30ostad;
2006. [In Persian].
58. Bryan E . Bledose RSp, Richard A . Chery MS EMT ‑ P.
Intermediate emergency care: principles & practice. Tehran 2007.
59. Samuel M, Galvagno DO Jr. Helicopter Emergency Medical
Services for Adults With Major Trauma. Baltimore, Maryland:
Johns Hopkins University; 2012.
60. Sullivent EE, Faul M, Wald MM. Reduced mortality in injured
adults transported by helicopter emergency medical services.
Prehosp Emerg Care 2011;15:295‑302.
61. Weinstein MC, Siegel JE, Gold MR, Kamlet MS, Russell LB.
Recommendations of the panel on cost‑effectiveness in health
and medicine. JAMA Surg 1996;276:1253‑8.
62. Sánchez‑Mangas R, García‑Ferrrer A, de Juan A, Arroyo AM. The
probability of death in road traffic accidents. How important is a
quick medical response? Accid Anal Prev 2010;42:1048‑56.
63. Goli, A , Gholinaghian, M, Rafiei, F . Multi‑detection location and
routing of rescue vehicles in crises with the purpose of reducing
relief times using covered tour approach and random simulation.
In: 12th International Industrial Engineering Conference. 2015.
https://civilica.com/doc/516011.
64. DemetriadesD, KimbrellB, SalimA, VelmahosG, RheeP, PrestonC,
et al. Trauma deaths in a mature urban trauma system: is ‘‘Trimodal’’
distribution a valid concept? J Am Coll Surg 2005;201:343‑8.
65. Global status report on road safety 2018. Geneva: World Health
Organization; 2018. Licence: CC BY‑NC‑SA 3.0 IGO.
66. Vijai MN, Ravi P R , Pathania A. Critical care air transport:
Experiences of a decade. JMR 2018;4:53‑8.
67. Spano SJ, Campagne D, Stroh G, Shalit M. A lightning multiple
casualty incident in Sequoia and Kings Canyon National Parks.
Wilderness Environ Med 2015;26:43‑53.
68. Bloch YH, Schwartz D, Pinkert M, Blumenfeld A, Avinoam S,
Hevion G, et al. Distribution of casualties in a mass‑casualty
incident with three local hospitals in the periphery of a densely
populated area: Lessons learned from the medical management
of a terrorist attack. Prehosp Disaster Med 2007;22:186‑92.
69. McGregor J, Hanlon N, Emmons S, Voaklander D, Kelly K. If all
ambulances could fly: Putting provincial standards of emergency
care access to the test in Northern British Columbia. Can J Rural
Med 2005;10:163‑8.
)