Document Type : Original Article
Authors
- . Apurva P Deshpande
- . Anil V Ankola
- . Roopali Sankeshwari
- . Sagar Jalihal
- . Deepika V Bhat
- . Abhra Roy Choudhury
- . Ram Surath Kumar
- . Atrey Pai Khot
Abstract
Appropriate oral health education (OHE) plays a vital role in prevention of oral diseases and would bridge
the gap between dentists and visually impaired individuals. Hence, this systematic review was planned
with an aim to evaluate effectiveness of various OHE techniques on the oral hygiene status and oral
health knowledge of visually impaired young individuals. An electronic search extended to September
30, 2020 was conducted on PubMed, Wiley, ProQuest, ScienceDirect, Cochrane library, EBSCO, and
Google Scholar. Two independent reviewers assessed the studies using a two‑stage process; data were
extracted according to PRISMA statement. Risk of bias assessment of selected studies was executed
according to the study designs. Meta‑analysis using the random‑effects model was conducted for the
outcomes for all oral health education techniques using STATASE 16.1 software. Hand and electronic
search identified 3829 articles. After screening for titles and duplicates, 37 articles were retrieved, which
were screened through abstract and full text. Of the 37 articles, 17 articles were included for qualitative
synthesis, and out of that, 13 were for meta‑analysis. Ten variations in oral health education (OHE)
techniques were used in the included 17 studies to impart oral health education to visually impaired
young individuals. Overall, all OHE techniques demonstrated a positive impact on oral hygiene status.
The pooled overall cumulative mean difference of the oral hygiene status after imparting education in
ATP, Audio, and Braille was 1.33 [1.06, 1.59], 1.76 [1.11, 2.42], and 1.96 [1.40, 2.55], respectively.
An appropriate OHE technique boosts confidence in visually impaired young individuals, making the
learning process an enjoyable experience. Use of either Braille or the ATP OHE technique was found
to be a reliable and useful method to improve oral hygiene of visually impaired young individuals.
Keywords
- Chang CH, ShihYH. Knowledge of dental health and oral hygiene
practices of Taiwanese visually impaired and sighted students.
J Vis Impair Blind 2004;98:289‑303.
2. Kumar RK, Fareed N, Shanthi M. The effectiveness of oral health
education program with and without involving self‑maintainable
oral hygiene skills among the visually impaired children. Int J Sci
Study 2013;1:51‑9.
3. Bourne RRA, Flaxman SR, Braithwaite T, Cicinelli MV, Das A,
Jonas JB, et al. Magnitude, temporal trends, and projections of
the global prevalence of blindness and distance and near vision
impairment: A systematic review and meta‑analysis. Lancet Glob
Health 2017;5:e888‑97.
4. Wadhwani M, Vashist P, Singh SS, Gupta V, Gupta N, Saxena R.
Prevalence and causes of childhood blindness in India:
A systematic review. Indian J Ophthalmol 2020;68:311‑5.
5. Al‑Alousi JMR. Oral health status and treatment needs among
blind children in Iraq. MDJ 2009;6:313‑24.
6. Al‑Qahtani C, Wyne AH. Caries experience and oral hygiene
status of blind, deaf and mentally retarded female children in
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Odontostomatol Trop 2004;27:37‑40.
7. Shetty V, Hegde AM, Bhandary S, Rai K. Oral health status of the
visually impaired children–a south Indian study. J Clin Pediatr
Dent 2010;34:213‑6.
8. Tagelsir A, Khogli AE, Nurelhuda NM. Oral health of visually
impaired schoolchildren in Khartoum State, Sudan. BMC Oral
Health 2013;13:33.
9. Singh N, Kaur G, Gumber PK, Kaur N. Oral health status of 6 to
15‑year‑old deaf and blind children of Sriganganagar. Int J Oral
Health Res Rev 2014;19:47‑55. - 10. Das D, Suresan V, Jnaneswar A, Pathi J, Bala Subramaniam G.
Effectiveness of a novel oral health education technique
in maintenance of gingival health and plaque removal
efficacy among institutionalized visually impaired children of
Bhubaneswar city: A randomized controlled trial. Spec Care
Dentist 2019;39:125‑34.
11. Deshpande S, Rajpurohit L, Kokka VV. Effectiveness of braille and
audio‑tactile performance technique for improving oral hygiene
status of visually impaired adolescents. J Indian Soc Periodontol
2017;21:27–31.
12. Krishnakumar R, Silla SS, Durai SK, Govindarajan M, Ahamed SS,
Mathivanan L. Comparative evaluation of audio and audio‑tactile
methods to improve oral hygiene status of visually impaired
school children. CHRISMED J Health Res 2016;3:55–9.
13. Hebbal M, Ankola AV. Development of a new technique (ATP) for
training visually impaired children in oral hygiene maintenance.
Eur Arch Paediatr Dent 2012;13:244–7.
14. Gautam A, Bhambal A, Moghe S. Impact of oral health education
by audio aids, braille and tactile models on the oral health status
of visually impaired children of Bhopal City. J Indian Soc Pedod
Prev Dent 2018;36:82–5.
15. Higgins JP, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ,
et al. editors. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of
Interventions. John Wiley & Sons; 2019.
16. Sterne JA, Hernán MA, Reeves BC, Savović J, Berkman ND,
Viswanathan M, et al. ROBINS‑I: A tool for assessing risk of bias
in non‑randomised studies of interventions. BMJ 2016;355:i4919.
17. McGuinness LA, Higgins JPT. Risk‑of‑bias VISualization (robvis):
An R package and Shiny web app for visualizing risk‑of‑bias
assessments. Res Synth Methods 2021;12:55‑61.
18. Khurana C, Tandon S, Chand S, Chinmaya BR. Effectiveness of
oral health education program using braille text in a group of
visually impaired children‑before and after comparison trial.
J Educ Health Promot 2019;8:50.
19. Debnath A, Srivastava BK, Shetty P, Eshwar S. New vision
for improving the oral health education of visually impaired
children‑a non randomized control trial. J Clin Diagn Res
2017;11:ZC29‑32.
20. Tiwari BS, Ankola AV, Jalihal S, Patil P, Sankeshwari RM,
Kashyap BR. Effectiveness of different oral health education
interventions in visually impaired school children. Spec Care
Dentist 2019;39:97‑107.
21. Aggarwal T, Goswami M, Dhillon JK. Assessment of Oral Health
Educational Program on oral health status of visually impaired
children in New Delhi. Spec Care Dentist 2019;39:140‑6.
22. Chowdary PB, Uloopi KS, Vinay C, Rao VV, Rayala C. Impact of
verbal, braille text, and tactile oral hygiene awareness instructions
on oral health status of visually impaired children. J Indian Soc
Pedod Prev Dent 2016;34:43.
23. Sardana D, Goyal A, Gauba K, Kapur A, Manchanda S. Effect
of specially designed oral health preventive programme on oral
health of visually impaired children: Use of audio and tactile aids.
Int Dent J 2019;69:98‑106.
24. Ganapathi AK, Namineni S, Vaaka PH, K V, Das R, Devi M, et al.
Effectiveness of various sensory input methods in dental health
education among blind children‑A comparative study. J Clin
Diagn Res 2015;9:ZC75‑8.
25. Deolia S, Johny J, Patil MS, Lanje NR, Patil AV. Effectiveness
of “Audio‑tactile Performance Technique” to improve the oral
hygiene status of visually impaired schoolchildren. J Indian Soc
Pedod Prev Dent 2019;37:172.
26. Kristiani A, Nugroho C. The effect of dental health education
audio media toward the knowledge and ohi‑s in visually impaired
students of Tasikmalaya Special Extraordinary School (SLB) year
2016. In Prosiding Seminar Bakti Tunas Husada 2017. Vol. 1.
27. Sharififard N, Sargeran K, Gholami M, Zayeri F. A music‑and
game‑based oral health education for visually impaired school
children; Multilevel analysis of a cluster randomized controlled
trial. BMC Oral Health 2020;20:1‑9.
28. Mahantesha T, Nara A, Kumari PR, Halemani PK, Buddiga V,
Mythri S. A comparative evaluation of oral hygiene using Braille
and audio instructions among institutionalized visually impaired
children aged between 6 years and 20 years: A 3‑monthfollow‑up
study. J Int Soc Prev Community Dent 2015;5(Suppl 2):S129‑32.
29. Bhor K, Shetty V, Garcha V, Nimbulkar GC. Effect of oral health
education in the form of Braille and oral health talk on oral
hygiene knowledge, practices, and status of 12–17 years old
visually impaired school girls in Pune city: A comparative study.
J Int Soc Prev Community Dent 2016;6:459‑64.
30. Pine CM. Community Oral Health. 2nd ed. Oxford: Wright; 1997.
p. 188–205.
31. Abedi N. Meta‑analysis of the effectiveness of educational
interventions on dental and oral health promotion in Iran. J Educ
Health Promot 2019;8:29.
32. Bhor KB, Vinay V, Ambildhok K, Shetty V. Effectiveness of
oral health educational interventions on oral health of visually
impaired school children: A systematic review and meta‑analysis.
Spec Care Dentist 2021;41:291‑308.
)